Driver Questions

When do I pay my deductible at the body shop?

Short answerWhen your repair is a claim under your own policy, you pay the deductible to the body shop when you pick up your vehicle. If the other driver’s insurance is paying, there is usually no deductible for you.
By Young’s Auto Body & Collision, Englewood, COReviewed November 2026

Your deductible is the first part of any covered loss under your own collision or comprehensive coverage. The insurer pays the approved repair cost minus the deductible, and the shop collects the deductible from you at pickup. If the insurer sent payments to you during the claim, you sign those over to the shop at that time as well.

What else is collected at pickup

Along with the deductible, you pay for any additional services you requested that were not part of the claim, and any betterment charges for worn parts that were replaced with new ones. See what is betterment for how that works.

Trunk lid and rear of a red sedan inside the Young’s Auto Body shop

About shops that offer to waive deductibles

Some shops advertise that they will cover or waive your deductible. In October 2025 the Colorado Division of Insurance issued Bulletin B-5.54 addressing repair shops that advertise or engage in waiving insurance deductibles owed by policyholders. You can read the Division’s announcement. If an offer sounds too good, ask how the repair is being paid for.

Do not skip the repair to keep the payout, either. If the same panel is damaged again later, the insurer has already paid for it once. Our insurance claim help page explains how we work with your insurer, and our free estimates show the costs up front. Contact us or call (303) 922-1300.

Key points

Deductible is paid at pickup
Applies to claims under your own policy
Usually no deductible when the other driver’s insurer pays
Insurer checks sent to you are signed over to the shop
Requested extras are paid separately
Betterment charges are collected at pickup
Colorado regulators have addressed deductible waivers
Keeping the payout without repairing can backfire
Questions

Deductible questions

Do I pay the deductible to the insurance company or the shop?

To the shop. The insurer pays the approved repair cost minus your deductible, and you pay the deductible to the shop at pickup.

Do I have a deductible if the other driver was at fault?

Usually not. When the other driver’s insurance is paying for the repair, you generally do not pay a deductible.

Can a body shop waive my deductible?

The Colorado Division of Insurance issued Bulletin B-5.54 in October 2025 addressing shops that advertise or engage in waiving deductibles owed by policyholders.

What if my insurer already sent me a check?

You sign it over to the shop at pickup, along with paying your deductible.

Been in an accident?

Get a free, insurance-ready estimate today. Early bird and night owl drop-off available.

Call (303) 922-1300 Request an Estimate

Areas We Serve

Englewood · Denver · Littleton · Sheridan · Cherry Hills Village · Centennial

Factory Certified

Ford · Subaru · Kia · Hyundai · Volkswagen

Services

Collision · Hail & PDR · Frame · Glass · Paint · Mechanical · Clear Bra · Theft Recovery