Driver Questions

My car was totaled. What happens next?

Short answerWhen an insurer declares your vehicle a total loss, it means repair costs exceed what the vehicle is worth. The insurer makes an offer based on comparable vehicles, and you usually choose between selling the vehicle to the insurer or keeping the salvage for a lower payout.
By Young’s Auto Body & Collision, Englewood, COReviewed November 2026

A total loss is an economic decision, not a statement that the vehicle cannot be fixed. The insurer compares the repair estimate to the vehicle’s value. If repairs cost more, the vehicle is totaled. That is why a shop’s accurate estimate matters, and why a supplement for hidden damage can sometimes turn a repair into a total loss partway through.

How the offer is set

The insurer’s offer is generally based on what comparable vehicles are selling for in your area, or on standard valuation guides. You can negotiate. Maintenance records, recent major repairs and new tires can all support a higher value. Ask for the comparable vehicles the insurer used.

Crushed rear structure of a red sedan after a collision, at Young’s Auto Body

Selling to the insurer or keeping the salvage

In most cases it is in your best interest to sell the vehicle to the insurance company. Once you agree on a final price, including tax, you sign a release and remove all personal items from the vehicle. If you keep the salvage, the insurer pays the vehicle value minus the salvage value, and you take responsibility for the vehicle. Note that if you decide not to repair a vehicle at a shop, the shop can charge for storage and teardown.

If your vehicle is borderline, an accurate estimate with documented structural measurements helps everyone make the right call. See our frame and unibody repair page, and what a frame estimate includes. Contact us or call (303) 922-1300.

Key points

Total loss means repairs exceed the vehicle’s value
Offers are based on comparable vehicles
You can negotiate the offer
Maintenance records can support a higher value
Selling to the insurer is usually simplest
Keeping salvage means a lower payout
Remove personal items before signing the release
Storage and teardown charges may apply
Questions

Total loss questions

Can I keep my car if it is totaled?

Usually, yes. The insurer pays the vehicle value minus the salvage value, and you keep the vehicle.

Can I negotiate a total loss offer?

Yes. Ask for the comparable vehicles used and provide records such as maintenance history or recent upgrades that support a higher value.

What do I need to do at the body shop?

Once a final price is agreed, you sign a release to the insurance company and remove all personal items from the vehicle.

Why did my repair become a total loss after teardown?

Hidden damage found during disassembly can raise repair costs above the vehicle’s value.

Been in an accident?

Get a free, insurance-ready estimate today. Early bird and night owl drop-off available.

Call (303) 922-1300 Request an Estimate

Areas We Serve

Englewood · Denver · Littleton · Sheridan · Cherry Hills Village · Centennial

Factory Certified

Ford · Subaru · Kia · Hyundai · Volkswagen

Services

Collision · Hail & PDR · Frame · Glass · Paint · Mechanical · Clear Bra · Theft Recovery