Driver Questions

Can I choose my own body shop in Colorado?

Short answerYes. In Colorado you have the right to choose the repair shop that fixes your vehicle. Your insurance company can recommend a shop, but it cannot make you use it.
By Young’s Auto Body & Collision, Englewood, COReviewed November 2026

The Colorado Division of Insurance states it plainly in its auto insurance guidance: consumers have the right to choose whichever repair shop they wish to use. Insurers may offer a network of preferred shops and may guarantee work done at those shops, but using one is your choice. You can read the Division’s guidance on its auto insurance page.

Why insurers recommend shops

Many insurers run direct repair programs, sometimes called DRP networks, with shops that agree to the insurer’s pricing and process. A recommended shop can be a perfectly good choice. The point is that it is a recommendation. If you prefer a shop with a particular manufacturer certification, a warranty you trust or a location that is convenient, you can take your vehicle there.

Red sedan outside Young’s Auto Body in Englewood

What changes if you choose your own shop

Usually very little. You still open the claim with your insurer and get a claim number. The shop you choose writes the estimate and works with the adjuster. According to the Division of Insurance, insurers generally pay reasonable market costs, but they may not pay additional fees or excessive costs charged by a repair facility, so it is worth choosing a shop that writes clear, insurer-ready estimates. Auto glass has its own protection: under C.R.S. 10-4-613, an insurer cannot require that glass repair or replacement be done by a particular facility as a condition of payment.

At Young’s we work with every insurance company and bill them directly. Our estimators write in Audatex, the system most insurers already use. See how we handle the process on our insurance claim help page, or read about collision repair and our free estimates. Ready to start? Contact us or call (303) 922-1300.

This page is general information, not legal advice. Policy terms vary, so review your own policy or ask your insurer about specifics.

Key points

Colorado drivers choose their own repair shop
Insurers may recommend preferred shops
A recommendation is not a requirement
Insurers pay reasonable market costs
You still open the claim with your insurer
The shop you choose works with the adjuster
Certifications and warranty are worth comparing
Glass work has its own Colorado protections
Questions

Choosing a shop: common questions

Will my insurance pay less if I do not use their preferred shop?

According to the Colorado Division of Insurance, insurers generally pay reasonable market costs for repairs. They may not pay additional fees or excessive costs charged by a repair facility.

Does choosing my own shop affect the warranty?

Insurers may guarantee work done at their preferred shops. A shop you choose provides its own warranty. At Young’s, labor carries a limited lifetime guarantee for as long as you own the vehicle.

Can my insurer require a specific glass company for my windshield?

Colorado law prohibits insurers from requiring that auto glass work be performed by a particular facility as a condition of payment.

What if the other driver’s insurance is paying?

You can still choose the shop that repairs your vehicle. Give the shop the claim number from the other driver’s insurer.

Been in an accident?

Get a free, insurance-ready estimate today. Early bird and night owl drop-off available.

Call (303) 922-1300 Request an Estimate

Areas We Serve

Englewood · Denver · Littleton · Sheridan · Cherry Hills Village · Centennial

Factory Certified

Ford · Subaru · Kia · Hyundai · Volkswagen

Services

Collision · Hail & PDR · Frame · Glass · Paint · Mechanical · Clear Bra · Theft Recovery